Caol Ila "Old Masters CS Selection", 12 yo. (d: 1994,b: 2006)
 
Style & Origin
styleScotch Single Malt Whisky
region Islay, North Shore
age12 yo.
strength59.5% (119 proof)
peatedyes
distilled1994
bottled2006
availabilityvery rare
bottler James MacArthur
distillery Caol Ila
Bar Log
Wed., Sep. 8, 2010bottle #349 donated by Jim Leuper
Mon., Sep. 27, 2010bottle #349 killed
Release Notes
An independent Old Masters bottling of a 1994 12yo. Caol Ila by James MacArthur. Bottled at full strength from cask# 2103.
Yours Truly
Regular Tasting Results
# Taster Date Nose Taste Finish Balance Total
1 David Drell 7 5 5 5 22
2 David Lawson 7 9 6 8 30
3 Doug Seiden 6 8 8 8 30
4 Jim Leuper 7 8 8 9 32
5 Kolja Erman 7 9 7 7 30
6 Robert Crawford 5 4 6 5 20
7 Stuart Campbell 7 8 8 6 29
Nose: peaty, bit floral, musty, undersells the taste
Taste: nagasaki of peat, with warm round notes as it settles
Finish: more of a fade (w/ bit of pepper) than a new chapter
Balance: such a strong presentation, tapers pleasantly, quite extraordinary up front. I'd keep it in my stable of foxy bottles.
David Lawson
Nose: pretty, peaty, sharp
Taste: bright, sweet start, mellows nicely with water
Finish: finishes sweet, perfumey, mellow
Balance: overall a bit sweet but very nice.
Doug Seiden
Nose: peaty - opens up nicely with a drop of water
Taste: great complexity, long lasting
Finish: smooth, even at cask strength. MUCH better with water. Outstanding
Balance: very well done - smooth, lots of omplexity, add a drop or two of water and it really opens up nicely.
Jim Leuper
Nose: savory dough under peat, subtle, water helps
Taste: lovely, hint of anise
Finish: could be bigger and longer, water expands it a bit but not enough
Balance: good stuff hiding which only really comes out in the middle.
Kolja Erman
Nose: sharp but interestingly quite pleasant, lemon + camomille
Taste: alcohol
Finish: long burn, alcohol with thick float over tongue(?)
Robert Crawford
Nose: strong alcohol initially giving way to a mix of peat + citrus
Taste: spectacular aggressive explosion up front of tangy, peaty strength
Finish: burning bitterness + sharpness holding in there for a good time
Balance: good start, falling off, left waiting for some more, but two good notes
Stuart Campbell
The Bottler: James MacArthur
Established: 1982
Silent since: False
Address: 20 Knights Templar Way, High Wycombe, Buckinghamshire, HP11 1PY, England
→ website
James MacArthur was established in 1982 with the aim of selecting whiskies from Scottish Distilleries which were either not very well known or had ceased to operate and bottling them at cask strength, thus introducing whisky drinkers to distilleries they had never heard of. This policy has been continued, with top quality single barrel bottlings from a wide selection of distilleries. Whiskies are currently bottled at ages ranging from 10 years to 35 years and at both cask strength and 43%vol. These are fine examples of the quality and variety available from each whisky producing region and the Company has won several awards for its bottlings, both internationally and in the UK. The most recent were Gold awards from the Whisky Magazines Independent Bottlers Challenge 2006. Cask strength whiskies are bottled at natural strength and without the whisky having been chill-filtered or having colour added. The 43% bottlings, although reduced in strength, are similarly non chill-filtered and have no added colour. The aim is to offer a product which is as natural as possible and which retains its original characteristics and flavours. Many of their whiskies have been matured in either bourbon barrels or sherry hogsheads and this adds a certain sweetness to the whisky, as well as colour. A drop of spring water added to a malt will open it up and improve both the aroma and the flavour. Appreciation of a good malt whisky on both the nose and the palate, takes time and not a little practice, but it is time well spent. What greater pleasure than a dram of good malt whisky. Even if a malt whisky is not necessary appreciated by everybody, the quality of the bottlings is guaranted.
This independent bottler (founded in 1982) nearly didn"t make it to the Malt Madness Independent Bottler list; many bottlings in their range were sub-standard and the shortage of useful information on most of James McArthur"s labels is very frustrating for malt maniacs that want to know as much as possible about what they"re drinking. For example, crucial details like the years of distillation and bottling are usually missing. Also, the labels don"t specify if colouring or chill filtration was used. Thanks to these idiosyncrasies the brand is not as interesting as some others from the perspective of malt whisky aficionado"s. The main series in James MacArthur"s portfolio is the "Old Masters" range (sometimes spelled as "Old Master"s" with an apostrophe). In recent years they started adding a vintage and a bottling year to the labels of most of these releases.
from Malt Madness, Whisky-Distilleries.info
The Distillery: Caol Ila
Established: 1846
Silent since: False
Address: Port Askaig, Isle Of Islay PA46 7RL, United Kingdom
→ website
2009 - A ten years old version of the unpeated variety is released at an even higher cask strength than the 8yo.
The Caol Ila distillery on Islay is located near Port Askaig, on the northeast corner of the island. It"s quite isolated, it"s closest neighbor being the Bunnahabhain distillery. Caol Ila was built in 1846 by Hector Henderson who also owned the old Camlachie distillery in Glasgow.
Although the profile of Caol Ila as a single malt has been enhanced in recent years, the main function of the distillery is still the production of malt whiskies for the Johnnie Walker blends. It might surprise you to learn that part of that whisky is actually unpeated - while Caol Ila is known mostly for their peated whiskies. The distillery actually started with trial runs with unpeated whisky in the 1980"s; the so-called "Highland" Caol Ila. For circa two decades this whisky was used almost exclusively for blends, but in 2006 it was introduced as an 8 years old single malt.
In the new Millenium
The Caol Ila distillery became part of the United Distillers conglommerate in 1986. In 1989 the first "semi-official" bottling of Caol Ila was released in the "Fauna & Flora" range. This would be the only official bottling in a long time (not counting the releases in UDV"s "Rare Malts" series). Fortunately, official bottlings are widely available these days.
Caol Ila"s current "core range" was introduced in 2002. Apart from the standard 12yo, 18yo and Cask Strength bottlings, Diageo releases occasional single cask bottlings as well. When casks of Lagavulin and Laphroaig became harder to acquire after the year 2000, independent bottlers started to release more and more private and "bastard" bottlings too.
Consecutive owners included Henderson, Lamont & Co (1852-1854), Norman Buchanan (1863-1879) and Bulloch, Lade & Co (proprietors of Camlachie) who rebuilt and expanded the distillery. Caol Ila was liquidated and sold to J. P. O"Brien Ltd in 1920, who in turn sold it to Caol Ila Distillery Co Ltd. the same year. DCL took control in 1927 and transferred Caol Ila to SMD in 1930 who shut it down. Caol Ila was silent until 1937 and had to close down during part of WWII as well.
These were the only periods Caol Ila was silent; despite the many changes in ownership Caol Ila has been in production almost constantly since 1846. After World War II, things proceeded relatively uneventful at Caol Ila for a few decades before it was rebuilt and extended from two to six stills between 1972 and 1974. The distillery was completely rebuilt in order to meet increased demand from the blenders, only the warehouses (still filled with maturing whisky) were spared. After 1974 Caol Ila started to buy their malted barley from the Port Ellen maltings. Some connoisseurs make a clear distinction between the heavier "old" Caol Ila that was produced before 1972 and the lighter, cleaner spirit that was distilled after the expansion in 1974.
2002 - Caol Ila has been one of Diageo"s "volume" distilleries for quite some time. Consequentially, the only (semi-) official releases were a "Flora & Fauna" bottling and a few "UD Rare Malts" expressions. However, at the start of the new millennium Diageo decided that they wanted to strengthen the Caol Ila brand. They introduced a range of official bottlings; the "standard" 12 years old, an 18 years old and a cask strength version (no age statement).
2006 - The Caol Ila "Unpeated" (formerly known as "Caol Ila Highland" to blenders) is released as a 8yo.
Trivia:
  • The name Caol Ila (pronounced as "kul-eela" and easily misspelled as Coal Ila) is Gaelic for "Sound of Islay" and is probably inspired by the location of the distillery along the stretch of water between Islay and Jura.
  • Caol Ila is the largest distillery on Islay by far; with an annual production capacity of almost 4 million litres of pure alcohol per year - about a quarter of all malt whisky that is distilled on the island. As such, Caol Ila"s capacity dwarfs well known malt whisky brands like Longmorn, Glenfarclas, Highland Park, Laphroaig and Lagavulin.
  • Although there is a three storey warehouse on the distillery grounds, these days the entire production is sent to the mainland via tanker trucks. So, young Caol Ila is not filled and matured on Islay.
  • After the distillery was remodeled and expanded in 1974 to better suit the needs of blenders Caol Ila introduced a novel new whisky for blenders in the mid 1980"s: an unpeated malt whisky known as "Caol Ila Highland ". This product was intended for blending and most (if not all) casks would thus have gone to blenders for, erm... blending. However, in 1999 Caol Ila resumed production of unpeated whisky for the "single malt" market. These bottlings became available in 2006 or 2007 when Diageo released the first bottling of the Caol Ila 8 Years Old "Unpeated". Since most blenders were not in the habit of storing their casks for very long (with the exception of Douglas Laing, perhaps) there probably are not that many casks of the unpeated Caol Ila Highland around - if any at all...
from Malt Madness
The Owner: Diageo
Established: 1997
Silent since: False
Address: 8 Henrietta Place, London, W1G ONB, UK
→ website
Diageo also distributes Unicum, its lighter-bodied variant Zwack and Jose Cuervo tequila products in North America. However, Cuervo operates as a separate company in Mexico and is not owned by Diageo. Similarly Grand Marnier is distributed by Diageo in many markets, including exclusively in Canada, and a deal was reached in 2009 to significantly expand this partnership in Europe.
Furthermore, Diageo owns the Gleneagles Hotel.
Diageo was formed in 1997 from the merger of Guinness plc and Grand Metropolitan plc. The creation was driven by the two executives Anthony Greener and Philip Yea at Guinness plus George Bull and John McGrath of Grand Metropolitan. The product portfolios of Guinness and Grand Met were largely complementary with little overlap.
Diageo is the world"s biggest whisky producer with 28 malt distilleries and two grain distilleries.The company operates the Scotch whisky distilleries of Auchroisk, Benrinnes, Blair Athol (situated at Pitlochry), Caol Ila, Cardhu, Knockando, Glen Elgin, Clynelish, Cragganmore, Dalwhinnie, Glenkinchie, Glen Ord, Lagavulin, Oban, Royal Lochnagar, Strathmill, Talisker, Teaninich, Mannochmore, Mortlach and Glenlossie, which are sold not only under their own name but used to make the various blended scotch whiskies sold by the company, and owns the stock of many closed distilleries such as Port Ellen, Rosebank, Brora, Convalmore, Glen Albyn, North Brechin, Banff, and Linlithgow. The company have opened a new malt distillery adjacent to their maltings at Roseisle (1st new make spirit produced Spring 2009). This will be one of the largest malt distilleries in Scotland. The new building contains 14 traditional copper pot stills. An expansion programme is also underway at its Cameron Bridge Grain Distillery in Fife that will make it the largest grain distillery in Scotland. Diageo also owns the Port Dundas Grain Distillery in Glasgow, and jointly operates the North British Grain Distillery in Gorgie, Edinburgh, with The Edrington Group.
Diageo plc (LSE: DGE, NYSE: DEO) is the largest multinational beer, wine and spirits company in the world. The company is listed on the London Stock Exchange and has American Depositary Receipts listed on the New York Stock Exchange. The word Diageo was formed from the Latin dia (day) and the Greek geo (World), symbolising the use of the company"s brands every day, everywhere. Its head office is located in the City of Westminster in London. It is a constituent of the FTSE 100 Index.
Trivia:
  • In December 2003, Diageo provoked controversy over its decision to change its Cardhu brand Scotch whisky from a single malt to a vatted malt (also known as a pure malt) whilst retaining the original name and bottle style. Diageo took this action because it did not have sufficient reserves to meet demand in the Spanish market, where Cardhu had been successful. After a meeting of producers, Diageo agreed to make changes.
  • In 2006, the Cardhu brand quietly changed back to being a single malt.
  • In July 2009, Diageo announced that, after nearly 200 years of association with the town of Kilmarnock, they would be closing the Johnnie Walker blending and bottling plant as part of restructuring to the business. This would make 700 workers unemployed and caused outrage from press, local people and politicians. A campaign against this decision was launched by the local SNP MSP Willie Coffey and Labour MP Des Browne. A petition was drawn up against the Diageo plans, which also involves the closure of the historic Port Dundas Grain Distillery in Glasgow.
  • In February 2009 it was reported in the Guardian that the company had restructured itself so as to avoid paying tax in the U.K., despite much of its profits being generated in the U.K.
  • Diageo is engaged in a tax scheme in the United States of America, commonly referred to as the "Rum Bailout", which will guarantee it USD$3 billion in revenues and profits.
  • The National Puerto Rican Coalitionplans to run a series of ads in New York City and Puerto Rico urging a boycott of Diageo-owned alcoholic drinks to protest the giant British-owned corporation"s controversial production move of its Captain Morgan rum from Puerto Rico to the U.S. Virgin Islands.
from Wikipedia