Balvenie "Rum Cask", 17 yo.
 
Style & Origin
styleScotch Single Malt Whisky
region Speyside, Dufftown
age17 yo.
strength43% (86 proof)
casksRum
price$60-180
availabilitywidely available
websitewww.thebalvenie.com
distillery Balvenie
Bar Log
Fri., Jan. 8, 2010bottle #278 donated by Kolja Erman
Fri., Jan. 8, 2010blind tasting of bottle #278
Fri., Mar. 5, 2010bottle #278 killed
Release Notes
A new 17yo Balvenie finished in a Jamaican rum cask, likely to appeal to fans of the successful 14yo Rum Wood expression released, er, three years previously.
The Whisky Exchange
3rd Party Tasting Notes
Nose: Hey - fresh and faintly chemical. Polished with light fruity notes. An explosion of complexity after a minute. Is this a finished whisky? Peanuts? Some Asian spices. Wood. Really makes quite an impression.
Taste: A tad weak, but then a very unique, complex fruitness pops up. Very entertaining.
The long finish is a tad dry before growing fruitier. Most likely a finished whisky - but I like it.
Score: 84 points - even in a blind tasting it was fairly obviously finished.
Malt Madness
Colour: full gold.
Nose: extremely rummy, to the point where it smells more like rum than like Balvenie. Distillery character not noticeable. Now, we like rum...
Mouth: very unusual again, more rum than whisky, let alone malt whisky or even Balvenie. Vanilla, molasses, very ripe bananas, even banana liqueur. Hints of dill.
Finish: long, even more on candy sugar and this 'greenness' that's so typical in most rums.
Comments: this premix is good but quite undetermined. Not really rum, not really single malt whisky... Sure one may rather buy 'true' whisky or 'true' rum, but I must say this mixture is good stuff on the palate.
Rating: 79 points.
Whisky Fun
Regular Tasting Results
# Taster Date Nose Taste Finish Balance Total
1 Alex Gurevich 8 7 6 6 27
2 Andrew Pilgrim 6 6 6 6 24
3 Andy Romine 9 8 7 8 32
4 Anthony Lanni 8 7 9 8 32
5 Barry Dempsey 7 5 4 4 20
6 Ben Kwa 4 4 5 6 19
7 Brent Watkins 6 7 5 8 26
8 Danik Thomas 6 7 8 7 28
9 David Drell 8 6 6 7 27
10 Doug Seiden 6 8 7 8 29
11 Erik Jasso 3 6 6 5 20
12 Jim Leuper 6 6 7 8 27
13 Russell Pearsall 4 5 3 7 19
14 Stan Haptas 8 9 9 9 35
15 Stuart Campbell 8 8 8 9 33
Nose: Floral, slightly sweet, hint of licorice
Taste: Spice up front, buttery, sea salt
Finish: Burns some, drops off to meh
Balance: The marriage is a little off-kilter
CommenTaste: Overall nice and enjoyable. But the whole experience is lacking.
Alex Gurevich
Nose: wonderfully smooth, floral
Taste: even on first sip right at home
Finish: finish has more burn than I'd expect
Comment: for a non-peaty scotch I like this quite a bit. Almost bourbony.
Andy Romine
Great nose, can't place the flavor. Tastes great too. Warm melodic after.
Anthony Lanni
Nose: Nice peaty nose
Taste: Strong (?)
Finish: More Peatiness, some burning, short
CommenTaste: Not my favorite, just ok.
Barry Dempsey
Nose: Sweet, fresh wood
Ben Kwa
Nice, spicy, but weak. I did just have the Sazerac 18yo though.
Brent Watkins
Nose; light on the nose
Taste: nice, balanced taste, not too peaty
Finish: it lingers longer, makes me want more
CommenTaste: Nice peaty balance; mellow nose on this; not too peaty, just enough for me.
Danik Thomas
Loved the nose. Taste wasn't too smokey which I like but didn't knock my socks off. Finished a lil more alcoholey than I like but still good.
David Drell
Nose: mellow, caramelly
Taste: nice mellow spice
Finish: a little hot but tasty
Balance: works well together
Doug Seiden
Nose: gives me a little bit of a headache
Taste: good. Could be better, but good.
Finish: mostly smooth... mostly
Balance: I don't know... average
Comment: A bit of a harsh smell and sharp taste at the end, but otherwise good. I'd drink it again.
Erik Jasso
Nose: nice, water didn't help
Taste: caramelly
Finish: brief, but pleasant
Balance: well balanced
Jim Leuper
Finish: dusty
CommenTaste: Medicinal nose. Slightly sour taste. Nicely blended, not sharp, good balance.
Russell Pearsall
Nose: sweet nose
CommenTaste: Oak barrel? Caramel? Peat! This is tasty! Guess it's a single malt... Glen-something.
Stan Haptas
Sweet tangy citrus nose. Fresh light fruity orange taste mixed in with peat flavor. Strong lasting warm end after a light fresh start. Delicate balance between the peat flavor with the fruit and hint of caramel + creamy.
Stuart Campbell
The Distillery: Balvenie
Established: 1892
Silent since: False
Address: Dufftown, Keith, Banffshire, AB55 4DH, Scotland, UK
→ website
2009 - It seems that rum finishes have grown increasingly popular with the people behind Balvenie; after releasing a 14yo in 2005 and a 17yo in 2008 they bottled two different 14yo"s in 2009; a "Cuban Selection" for France and a "Golden Cask" version for the duty free market.
The Balvenie distillery in Dufftown was built in 1892 by W. & J. Grant, owners of the Glenfiddich distillery nearby. More than a century later they are still "sister stills", owned by the very same company that originally built them; William Grant & Sons.
And after having sampled it I can say that this 6yo old vatted malt whisky can"t hold a candle to the older, official bottlings of Balvenie, or to Glenfiddich OB"s for that matter. In fact, I haven"t tried a bad Balvenie yet and its sister distillery Glenfiddich seems on the way up as well. An old "Over 8yo" expression bottled in the 1960"s was much better than any Glenfiddich from the 1990"s (except the 15yo Cask Strength perhaps), but the third millennium looks promising...
In the New Millenium:
As you can see at the left, the official bottlings are beautifully designed. Well, actually, official bottlings are all you"re likely to find; the "brand" is jealously protected and just like Glenfiddich, independent bottlings are very rare. That being said, I"ve tried an excellent 31yo Glenfiddich from Cadenhead"s and the maniacs found some independently owned casks of Balvenie as well. but these are exceptions. Ordinarily, every single cask of Balvenie or Glenfiddich that is sold to brokers or blenders is "polluted" with a small quantity of the other malt, making it a vatted malt. That means that it"s illegal to sell this malt whisky ("Wardhead" is the name for Glenfiddich with a dash of Balvenie while "Burnside" is Balvenie with a little Glenfiddich) as a single malt whisky.
I"ve actually tried one of these vatted malts - although I"m not sure which one. The "Burn of Speyside" 6yo 1996 vatted malt is sold in Holland by Van Wees. They"ve added a charming little story about a sunken ship (a la Whisky Galore) but research by Robin Brilleman has shown that it was just a "fender bender". Balvenie logo
When the distillery was built in 1892 it was outfitted with second hand still from Lagavulin and Glen Albyn. This might seem a bit odd at first, but the use of second hand stills from other distilleries that were demolished or refurbished is actually not that uncommon. These days Balvenie has no less than eight stills (4 wash stills and 4 spirit stills); two of them were added in 1965 and one in 1971.
The official Balvenie core range includes the standard 10 years old "Founders Reserve", the 12yo "DoubleWood", the 15yo "Single Barrel" (shown in the picture at the left) and the 21yo "Port Wood". Actually, that"s just the "core" core range - the 25yo "Single Barrel" is a fairly regular release and bottlings like the 1989 and 1991 "Port Wood" and the 17yo "Islay Cask" were available for a longer period of time as well. (See the Balvenie website for the details of their current range.) Balvenie also provides a fine example of the irrelevance of the "terroir" theories on Scotch whisky in modern times. Balvenie and Glenfiddich are located next to each other and use the same water source. Nevertheless, the whiskies are quite different from each other...
2001 - The Balvenie Islay Cask is launched. This whisky has been aged in bourbon casks for 17 years before it"s finished in an "Islay cask". That"s supposedly a cask that has previously contained a malt whisky from Islay. So, I guess you could call this a whisky with a whisky finish...
2005 - The Balvenie 14yo Rum Wood Finish is released; another double matured whisky in a growing list of finished whiskies released by Balvenie. Arguably their Balvenie DoubleWood has always remained their most popular "finish".
Trivia:
  • A 50yo Balvenie from 1952 was released in 2002; after half a century cask #191 still produced 83 bottles. The recommended retail price of these bottles was a whopping 6,000 GBP.
  • Balvenie still has its own floor maltings, but they can only produce a fraction (circa 15%) of all the malted barley that Balvenie needs to keep production going.
  • Balvenie is one of almost two dozen malt whisky distilleries that were founded during the "whisky boom" of the late 19th century and which have managed to survive until this day. The other survivors include Aberfeldy, Ardmore, Aultmore, Benriach, Benromach, Bruichladdich, Bunnahabhain, Craigellachie, Dalwhinnie, Dufftown, Glendullan, Glenfiddich, Glen Moray, Glenrothes, Glentauchers, Knockandu, Knockdhu, Longmorn, Tamdhu and Tomatin.
from Malt Madness
The Owner: William Grant & Sons
Established: 1886
Silent since: False
Address: Phoenix Crescent Strathclyde Business Park, Bellshill, Lanarkshire, ML4 3AN, UK
→ website
William Grant & Sons Ltd. is an independent, family-owned Scottish company which distills Scotch whisky and other selected categories of spirits. It was founded in 1886 by William Grant, and is now run by the descendants of the founder. It is the largest of the handful of Scotch whisky distillers remaining in family ownership. "William Grant & Sons" is often abbreviated to "W. Grant & Sons" or just "Grant"s", after their leading blended whisky of the same name.
William Grant & Sons pioneered single malt Scotch whisky as until Glenfiddich, only blended brands were common In 1997 the Grant entered into a joint venture with the Robertson family (The Edrington Group) creating a new company, Highland Distillers.
The company"s leading single malt Scotch brand is Glenfiddich, the best-selling brand in the worldwide single malt Scotch market (700,000 cases/year and 17.37% market share). This is more than the sales of the next two single malts combined. Their leading blended Scotch brand is Grant"s, the 4th best-selling brand in the worldwide blended Scotch market and the Scotch market as a whole (4 million cases/year). Grant"s is also the 4th best-selling brand in the domestic United Kingdom Scotch market (420,000 cases/year and 14.6% market share).
William Grant was born in Dufftown in 1839. The young Grant worked at Mortlach Distillery and dreamed of one day running his own distillery. He worked hard and saved and in 1886 Grant and his 9 children laid the first stone of the Glenfiddich Distillery. It was Christmas day 1887 when the first spirit ran from the stills.
In 1892 William Grant & Sons bought a second neighbouring Distillery called Balvenie. In 1898 the two distilleries started blending their whiskies and Grant"s Whisky was "born".
The company is the 3rd largest producer of Scotch whisky (10.4% market share) after Diageo (34.4%), and Pernod Ricard. The company"s central headquarters are in Strathclyde Business Park, North Lanarkshire. Sales and marketing headquarters are in Richmond, London. The company is a member of the Scotch Whisky Association.
The master blender of Grant"s is David Stewart, who has been in his post for 47 years, the longest serving master blender with one distiller in the industry.
Core brands include: Glenfiddich, Grant"s, Balvenie, Hendrick"s Gun, Sailor Jerry Rum. Other brands include: Reyka Iclandic Vodka, Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum, Old Vatted Demerara Rum, Wood"s 100 Old Navy Rum, Vat 19 Rum, Gibson"s Finest, Clan MacGregor Blended Whisky, Monkey Shoulder Triple Malt Whisky, Taboo, Milagro Tequila, Solerno. The company also produces a number of rare whiskies such as Girvan First Batch (from 1964 casks) and Ladyburn (silent distillery closed in 1975) as well private vintage bottlings. Via Highland Distillers the company has a stake in the following brands: The Famous Grouse, The Macallan, Highland Park, Black Bottle and Gloag"s Dry Gin. The company has also co-developed Virgin Vodka with Richard Branson"s Virgin Group
The company owns several distilleries including Glenfiddich, Balvenie, Girvan Grain Distillery, Convalmore (only the bonded warehouse), Kininvie and Ailsa Bay Distillery.
Trivia:
  • allegedly the first company to market Scotch whisky abroad (this claim is very contentious - there are several, particularly Glen Grant and Glenmorangie, which would dispute it)
  • revolutionized bottle design in the 1950s, creating a triangular bottle
  • was the first to open up its distillery to visitors
  • introduced the solera concept to Glenfiddich to create Glenfiddich Solera Reserve
from Wikipedia